Secular Humanism, Part I
Secular Humanism
Let’s begin with the Secular Humanist World View simply because it is the dominant world view of these United States of America (most of Europe and most if not all world governments). Yes, you read the last sentence correctly! But, before we begin our journey, let me briefly review the elements of a world view for there are at least eleven elements that most scholars can agree to. These are: source documents, theology, philosophy, ethics, biology, psychology, sociology, law, politics, economics, and history. We will summarize each of these elements for each of the world view so that you the reader can quickly grasp the fundamental perspective guiding the interpretation and application of each world view element. But, first, some history.
Origins of Humanism
The history of the term humanism is complex but enlightening. It was first employed (as humanismus) by 19th-century German scholars to designate the Renaissance emphasis on classical studies in education. These studies were pursued and endorsed by educators known, as early as the late 15th century, as umanisti—that is, professors or students of Classical literature. The word umanisti derives from the studia humanitatis, a course of classical studies that, in the early 15th century, consisted of grammar, poetry, rhetoric, history, and morality. Although the term “humanism” was not applied to a philosophy or belief system until the European Renaissance, perhaps the earliest person we might be able to call a “humanist” in some sense would be Protagoras, the Greek philosopher and teacher who lived around the 5th century BCE. Early humanists shared in large part a realism that rejected traditional assumptions and aimed instead at the objective analysis of perceived experience. To humanism is owed the rise of modern science and social sciences, which emerged not as academic disciplines, but rather as practical instruments of environmental and social self-inquiry. Without humanist it is safe to say that the iPhone and all that lead to it would not be part of our history; but this is an exaggerated over simplification. As with any World View, a world view carried out to excess leads ultimately to tyranny and despotism.
Secular Humanism
Secular Humanism, a 20th century development with roots in ancient Greek philosophy, refers to an ideology that bases its morality and decision-making on the humanist values of reason, justice, and ethics instead of the spiritual and supernatural claims of most religious traditions. Secular Humanism does not reject the existence of God or the supernatural (preferring the label “non-theistic” as opposed to atheistic), but it does not believe these should be sources of social, ethical, or moral reflection and organization. However, its major historical apologists are all themselves self declared atheists. As a philosophical approach, Secular Humanism looks to human beings to solve human problems instead of looking to a god. Secular Humanism is distinguished by its desire to separate itself from other forms of humanism including realism, philosophical humanism, scientific humanism, and in particular religious humanism and Christian humanism. Secular Humanism as a movement is committed to the growth and fulfillment of individuals and humanity through the use of critical reason and scientific methods. It aims to search for ethical principles that guide individuals and communities in social and political engagement. Secular Humanism is grounded in the conviction that by employing reason, tolerance, and good will, humanity is capable of creating a better world. Secular Humanists are typically nonreligious. However, Secular Humanism is itself a religion not because it has a “governing body” (the Council for Secular Humanism) and recognized “texts” (such as the Secular Humanist Manifestos I, II, and III), but because Secular Humanism is a belief system with its own faith statement: “Secular Humanism is grounded in the conviction that by employing reason, tolerance, and good will, humanity is capable of creating a better world.”
The “bottom line” then for the Secular Humanist is that man is the center of his universe — not a god, or God. It is this central “theme” from which the Secular Humanist interprets the realities of his world; it is the lens through which the Secular Humanist views the world around him.
Sacred Documents
A Humanist Manifesto, also known as Humanist Manifesto I to distinguish it from later Humanist Manifestos in the series, was written in 1933 primarily by Raymond Bragg and published with 34 signers. Unlike the later manifestos, this first talks of a new religion and refers to humanism as a religious movement meant to transcend and replace previous, deity-based systems. Nevertheless, it is careful not to express a creed or dogma. The document outlines fifteen affirmations on cosmology, biological and cultural evolution, human nature, epistemology, ethics, religion, self-fulfillment, and the quest for freedom and social justice. This latter, stated in article fourteen, proved to be the most controversial, even among humanists, in its opposition to “acquisitive and profit-motivated society” and its call for an egalitarian world community based on voluntary mutual cooperation. The document’s release was reported by the mainstream media on May 1, simultaneous with its publication in the May/June 1933 issue of the New Humanist.
Two manifestos followed: Humanist Manifesto II of 1973 and Humanism and Its Aspirations of 2003. See, Resource heading, “Humanism,” for a reading of Humanist Manifestos I, II, and III.
The Humanist Manifesto II was written in 1973 by Paul Kurtz and Edwin H. Wilson, and was intended to update the Manifesto I. It begins with a statement that the excesses of Nazism and world war had made the first seem “far too optimistic”, and indicated a more hardheaded and realistic approach in its seventeen-point statement, which was much longer and more elaborate than the previous version. Nevertheless, much of the unbridled optimism of the first remained, with hopes stated that war would become obsolete and poverty would be eliminated.
Many of the proposals in the document, such as opposition to racism and weapons of mass destruction and support of strong human rights, are fairly uncontroversial, and its prescriptions that divorce and birth control should be legal and that technology can improve life are widely accepted today in the Western world. Furthermore, its proposal of an international court has since been implemented. However, in addition to its rejection of religion, various controversial stances are strongly supported, notably the right to abortion.
Initially published with a small number of signatures, the document was circulated and gained thousands more, and indeed the AHA website encourages visitors to add their own name. A provision at the end that the signators do “not necessarily endorse every detail” of the document, but only its broad vision, no doubt helped many overcome reservations about attaching their name.
One of the oft-quoted lines comes from this manifesto is, “No deity will save us; we must save ourselves.”
The Humanist Manifesto II first appeared in The Humanist September / October, 1973, when Paul Kurtz and Edwin H. Wilson were editor and editor emeritus respectively.
Humanism and Its Aspirations subtitled Humanist Manifesto III, a successor to the Humanist Manifesto of 1933 is the most recent of the Humanist Manifestos published in 2003 by the American Humanist Association (AHA). The newest one is much shorter, listing six primary beliefs, which echo themes from its predecessors:
- Knowledge of the world is derived by observation, experimentation, and rational analysis. (See empiricism.)
- Humans are an integral part of nature, the result of unguided evolutionary change.
- Ethical values are derived from human need and interest as tested by experience. (See ethical naturalism.)
- Life’s fulfillment emerges from individual participation in the service of humane ideals.
- Humans are social by nature and find meaning in relationships.
- Working to benefit society maximizes individual happiness.
These are the major Sacred Documents for the Secular Humanist, with minor manifestos in 1980 and again in 2000.
Signatories of, A Humanist Manifesto I
Of the 65 people who were asked to sign, 34 accepted. About half (15) were Unitarians. [1] The 34 were:
- J.A.C. Fagginger Auer (Parkman Professor of Church History and Theology, Harvard University; Professor of church history, Tufts College.)
- E. Burdette Backus (Unitarian minister.)
- Harry Elmer Barnes (general editorial department, Scripps-Howard Newspapers.)
- L.M. Birkhead (the Liberal Center, Kansas City, Missouri.)
- Raymond B. Bragg (secretary, Western Unitarian Conference.)
- Edwin Arthur Burtt (professor of philosophy, Sage School of Philosophy, Cornell University.)
- Ernest Caldecott (minister, First Unitarian Church, Los Angeles, California.)
- A.J. Carlson (professor of physiology, University of Chicago.)
- John Dewey (Columbia University.)
- Albert C. Dieffenbach (former editor of the Christian Register.)
- John H. Dietrich (minister, First Unitarian Society, Minneapolis.)
- Bernard Fantus (professor of therapeutics, College of Medicine, University of Illinois.)
- William Floyd (editor of the Arbitrator, New York City.)
- F.H. Hankins (professor of economics and sociology, Smith College.)
- A. Eustace Haydon (professor of history of religions, University of Chicago.)
- Llewellyn Jones (literary critic and author.)
- Robert Morss Lovett (editor, The New Republic; professor of English, University of Chicago.)
- Harold P. Marley (minister, the Fellowship of Liberal Religion, Ann Arbor, Michigan.)
- R. Lester Mondale (minister, Unitarian Church, Evanston, Illinois.)
- Charles Francis Potter (leader and founder, the First Humanist Society of New York, Inc.)
- John Herman Randall, Jr. (department of philosophy, Columbia University.)
- Curtis W. Reese (dean, Abraham Lincoln Center, Chicago.)
- Oliver L. Reiser (associate professor of philosophy, University of Pittsburgh.)
- Roy Wood Sellars (professor of philosophy, University of Michigan.)
- Clinton Lee Scott (minister, Universalist Church, Peoria, Illinois.)
- Maynard Shipley (president, the Science League of America.)
- W. Frank Swift (director, Boston Ethical Society.)
- V.T. Thayer (educational director, Ethical Culture Schools.)
- Eldred C. Vanderlaan (leader of the Free Fellowship, Berkeley, California.)
- Joseph Walker (attorney, Boston, Massachusetts.)
- Jacob J. Weinstein (rabbi; advisor to Jewish Students, Columbia University.)
- Frank S.C. Wicks (All Souls Unitarian Church, Indianapolis.)
- David Rhys Williams (minister, Unitarian Church, Rochester, New York.)
- Edwin H. Wilson (managing editor, the New Humanist, Chicago, Illinois; minister, Third Unitarian Church, Chicago, Illinois.)
A 35th signature, that of Alson Robinson, came in too late for it to be published with the other 34.
Signatories of, A Humanist Manifesto II
The 120 signatories to the manifesto included the following:
From Britain:
- H. J. Blackham
- Brigid Brophy
- Francis Crick
- H. J. Eysenck
- Raymond Firth
- Antony Flew
- Hector Hawton
- James Hemming
- Margaret Knight
- Ritchie Calder
From the United States of America:
From Yugoslavia
From the USSR:
A complete list of signatories of Humanist Manifesto II can be found at http://www.americanhumanist.org/Who_We_Are/About_Humanism/Humanist_Manifesto_II
Signatories of, Humanist Manifest III
The following academics and other prominent persons were signatories to the document, who signed the statement “We who sign Humanism and Its Aspirations declare ourselves in general agreement with its substance”:
Notable Signatories
- Philip Appleman (Poet and distinguished professor emeritus of English, Indiana University)
- Khoren Arisian (Senior Leader, NY Society for Ethical Culture)
- Bill Baird (Reproductive rights pioneer)
- Frank Berger (Pharmacologist, developer of anti-anxiety drugs)
- Howard Box (Minister emeritus, Oak Ridge Unitarian Universalist Church, Tennessee)
- Lester R. Brown (Founder and president, Earth Policy Institute)
- August E. Brunsman IV (Executive director, Secular Student Alliance)
- Rob Buitenweg (Vice president, International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- Vern Bullough (Sexologist and former copresident of the International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- David Bumbaugh (Professor, Meadville Lombard Theological School)
- Matthew Cherry (Executive director, Institute for Humanist Studies)
- Joseph Chuman (Visiting professor of religion, Columbia University, and leader, Ethical Culture Society of Bergen County, New Jersey)
- Curt Collier (leader, Riverdale-Yonkers Society for Ethical Culture, New York)
- Fred Cook (Retired executive committee member, International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- Carleton Coon (Former US Ambassador to Nepal)
- Richard Dawkins (Charles Simonyi professor, University of Oxford)
- Charles Debrovner (President, NACH/Humanist Institute)
- Arthur Dobrin (Professor of humanities, Hofstra University and leader emeritus Ethical Humanist Society of Long Island, New York)
- Margaret Downey (President, Freethought Society of Greater Philadelphia)
- Sonja Eggerickx (Vice president, Unie Vrijzinnige, Belgium, and vice president International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- Riane Eisler (President, Center for Partnership Studies)
- Albert Ellis (Creator of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy and founder of the Alber Ellis Institute)
- Edward L. Ericson (Leader emeritus, Ethical Culture)
- Roy P. Fairfield (Cofounder, Union Graduate School)
- Antony Flew (Philosopher)
- Levi Fragell (President, International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- Arun Gandhi (Cofounder, M.K. Gandhi Institute for Nonviolence)
- Kendyl Gibbons (President, Unitarian Universalist Ministers Association)
- Babu R.R. Gogineni (Executive director, International Humanist and Ethical Union)
- Sol Gordon (Sexologist)
- Ethelbert Haskins (Retired treasurer of the Humanist Foundation)
- Jim Herrick (Editor, the New Humanist)
- Pervez Hoodbhoy (Professor of physics at Quaid-e-Azam University, Islamabad, Pakistan)
- Fran P. Hosken (Editor, Women’s International Network News)
- Joan Johnson Lewis (President, National Leaders Council of the American Ethical Union)
- Stefan Jonasson (Immediate past president, HUUmanists)
- Larry Jones (President, Institute for Humanist Studies)
- Edwin Kagin (Founder and director, Camp Quest)
- Beth Lamont (AHA NGO representative to the United Nations)
- Gerald A. Larue (Professor emeritus of biblical history and archaeology, University of Southern California)
- Joseph Levee (Board member, Council for Secular Humanism)
- Ellen McBride (Immediate past president, American Ethical Union)
- Lester Mondale (Retired Unitarian Universalist minister and signer of Humanist Manifestos I and II)
- Henry Morgentaler (Abortion rights pioneer)
- Stephen Mumford (President, Center for Research on Population and Security)
- William Murry (President and dean, Meadville-Lombard Theological School)
- Sarah Oelberg (President, HUUmanists)
- Indumati Parikh (President, Center for the Study of Social Change, India)
- Philip Paulson (Church-state activist)
- Katha Pollitt (Columnist, the Nation)
- Howard Radest (Dean emeritus, the Humanist Institute)
- James “Amazing” Randi (Magician, founder of the James Randi Educational Foundation)
- Larry Reyka (President, the Humanist Society)
- David Schafer (Retired research physiologist, U.S. Veterans Administration)
- Eugenie Scott (Executive director, National Center for Science Education)
- Michael Shermer (Editor of Skeptic magazine)
- James R. Simpson (Professor of international agricultural economics, Ryukoku University, Japan)
- Warren Allen Smith (Editor and author)
- Matthew les Spetter (Associate professor in social psychology at the Peace Studies Institute of Manhattan College, NY)
- Oliver Stone (Academy award-winning filmmaker)
- John Swomley (Professor emeritus of social ethics, St. Paul School of Theology)
- Robert Tapp (Dean, the Humanist Institute)
- Carl Thitchener (Co-minister, Unitarian Universalist Church of Amherst and of Canandaigua, New York)
- Maureen Thitchener (Co-minister, Unitarian Universalist Church of Amherst and of Canandaigua, New York)
- Rodrigue Tremblay (Emeritus professor of economics and of international finance, Universite de Montreal, Quebec, Canada)
- Kurt Vonnegut (Novelist)
- John Weston[disambiguation needed] (Ministerial settlement director, Unitarian Universalist Association)
- Edward O. Wilson (Professor, Harvard University, and two-time Pulitzer Prize winner)
- Sherwin Wine (Founder and president, Society for Humanistic Judaism)
Nobel laureates
21 Nobel laureates signed the statement, these being:
- Philip W. Anderson (Physics, 1977)
- Paul D. Boyer (Chemistry, 1997)
- Owen Chamberlain (Physics, 1959)
- Francis Crick (Medicine, 1962)
- Paul J. Crutzen (Chemistry, 1995)
- Pierre-Gilles de Gennes (Physics, 1991)
- Johann Deisenhofer (Chemistry, 1988)
- Jerome I. Friedman (Physics, 1990)
- Sheldon Glashow (Physics, 1979)
- Herbert A. Hauptman (Chemistry, 1985)
- Dudley Herschbach (Chemistry, 1986)
- Harold W. Kroto (Chemistry, 1996)
- Yuan T. Lee (Chemistry, 1986)
- Mario J. Molina (Chemistry, 1995)
- Erwin Neher (Medicine, 1991)
- Ilya Prigogine (Chemistry, 1977)
- Richard J. Roberts (Medicine, 1993)
- John E. Sulston (Medicine, 2002)
- Henry Taube (Chemistry, 1983)
- E. Donnall Thomas (Medicine, 1990)
- James Dewey Watson (Medicine, 1962)
Past AHA presidents
- Edd Doerr
- Michael W. Werner
- Suzanne I. Paul
- Lyle L. Simpson
- Bette Chambers
- Lloyd L. Morain
- Robert W. McCoy
- Vashti McCollum
AHA board
The then-current AHA board all signed, these being:
- Melvin Lipman (president)
- Lois Lyons (vice president)
- Ronald W. Fegley (secretary)
- John Nugent (treasurer)
- Wanda Alexander
- John Cole
- Tom Ferrick
- Robert Finch
- John M. Higgins
- Herb Silverman
- Maddy Urken
- Mike Werner
Drafting committee
Finally, there was the drafting committee of:
- Fred Edwords (chair)
- Edd Doerr (also included above as a past president of the AHA)
- Tony Hileman
- Pat Duffy Hutcheon
- Maddy Urken