Archive for the ‘Editorial Page’ Category

A Fresh Call for Debate

Tuesday, August 18th, 2009

As we continue to see sensationalized images of ranting citizens in various Town Hall meetings on the evening news, one might ask what the cause of this outrage is.  There are many reasons for and from which Town Hall participants draw strength to challenge their Congress men and women.  Among the many reasons is fear of change of any kind, a misunderstanding of the facts, or they are downright misinformed acting on out-and-out lies about the issue, or more probable—Town Haller’s might have a gut feeling that there is something just plain wrong about the issue and the information that they receive from the media and government representatives.  Combine strong suspicions with real fear and what you often times get is wild-eyed outrageous conduct by people who are otherwise collected intellectually and personally.    It would be nice if we could all live in a Pollyanna world—or even better, Lake Woebegone!  In addition to all the other attributes of Lake Woebegone, all of our politicians, judges, appointed officials, and bureaucrats would be totally honest, morally upstanding, and perhaps even transparent in motive; none would have hidden agendas and certainly no conspiratorial thoughts to over throw the U. S. Constitution, or to destroy the very foundations and traditions of our nation as some Town Haller’s suggest.   But, history from Genghis Khan and before to the present day tells us clearly that such a world is not reality; human nature is what it is, and that there have always been those who would challenge and to challenge by force if necessary for our own good to redirect a nation and reshape it in their own image at the expense of thousands, e.g. Russia, 1917; Germany, 1933; Iran, present day!  What we witness is a continuous, ongoing conflict of world views!

I might add here that some people in the media who laugh at or become indignant over the ideas of others who raise images of our collective history in the form of Hitler or Stalin suggest that we here in the United States of America are somehow immune to such extremism and further that those in positions of power and authority here (or they in the media themselves) are somehow intellectually superior to and therefore incapable of such extremism as these an other historical personalities exemplify.   To so smugly dismiss these historical images is naïve at best as educated citizens of world history and persons of some responsibility, or supremely arrogant; either is reprehensible!    (more…)

Town Hall Meetings

Thursday, August 13th, 2009

When is a Town Hall not a Town Hall?

There is much in the “news” of late about town hall meetings and the wracking-over -the-coals that many of our representative congress men and women are taking.   (Perhaps our trusted congress men and women would be advised to conduct such meeting on a more regular bases should they truly be interested in the opinions of those they claim to represent.  The anger level they encounter might well be much less!)  True Town Hall Meetings are just what we see in the “news” with the exception that the in-your-face, finger wagging, or fist waving confrontations are not representative of the general character of most Town Hall Meetings—at least not in my personal experience.  Shouting, yes!  Heated discussion, yes!  Passionate exchanges, yes!  But Town Hall Meetings can also be rather boring at times and frequently uneventful.   But, since the “news” is not usually anything less than the sensational most prime time TV news editors and newspaper front page boards would not find such Town Hall Meetings with well behaved citizen very interesting, and more to the point—in keeping with the picture of “reality” that they want to present that supports their internal editorial positions or support of one political party or another, or a political position on an issue of their choice. (more…)

Where Have All The Journalists Gone?

Monday, August 10th, 2009

While there is much talk about “angry mobs” stuffing local health-care town hall meeting providing much grist and chaff for morning and evening TV “news” show round-table discussions, such talk in total add little if anything to real solutions to the general problem of health-care in America.

 With countless hours per week of TV time, TV news shows like Joe Scarborough’s, Morning  Joe , or Bill O’Reilly’s, The O’Reilly Factor,  these and other TV news media could become part of the solution by providing real insight into and reasoned explanations of HR3200.  I am sure that Fox News and MSNBC as two examples have access to experts on HR3200 who could come to their programs as featured guests to review the actual proposed legislation and explain the legislation in clear language for all of us to understand.  What a service Fox, NBC, ABC, and CBS—the former leader for news content—could provide!  Think about it; just 10 minutes a day in review of a portion of the proposed health-care legislation could provide all of us with information that might be used to answer many of the questions Town Hall goers and others of us have about what might become THE major historical event of U.S. history outside of the Revolution and the Civil War.  TV news, what is now more entertainment than real down to earth journalism could become part of the solution!  Joe (Mika and Willie) and Bill could provide a kind of mini Edward R. Murrow, ‘White Paper’ Report on HR3200 and in so doing step up to meet their journalistic responsibilities.

With every great freedom there is also a great responsibility.

Could it be that the people who run the ‘news divisions’ of the major networks are more interested in ratings and profits than becoming part of the solution?  Could the Joes’ and the Bills’ of journalistic theater be more interested in their personal well being rather than the hard work of digging for usable information and facts, and the root of the story?  Or is there something more politically sinister going on here as suggested by some of the political fringe Black Helicopter groups?  Only the final outcome will tell us!

D. M. Elmquist, Editor